© 2026 WUKY
background_fid.jpg
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

'We need court reform': UK election law analyst assesses Biden's SCOTUS proposals

FILE - The Supreme Court is pictured, June 30, 2024, in Washington. President Joe Biden went public Monday, July 29, with major changes he's proposing for the Supreme Court: an enforceable code of ethics, term limits for justices and a constitutional amendment that would limit the justices' recent decision on presidential immunity. There's almost no chance of the proposal passing a closely divided Congress, but the ideas could still spark conversation with public confidence in the court hitting an all-time low in recent years amid ethical revelations about some justices. (AP Photo/Susan Walsh, File)
Susan Walsh/AP
/
AP
FILE - The Supreme Court is pictured, June 30, 2024, in Washington. President Joe Biden went public Monday, July 29, with major changes he's proposing for the Supreme Court: an enforceable code of ethics, term limits for justices and a constitutional amendment that would limit the justices' recent decision on presidential immunity. There's almost no chance of the proposal passing a closely divided Congress, but the ideas could still spark conversation with public confidence in the court hitting an all-time low in recent years amid ethical revelations about some justices. (AP Photo/Susan Walsh, File)

A University of Kentucky election law expert says President Joe Biden’s proposed changes for the U.S. Supreme Court would help restore confidence at a time with dismal polls showing an all-time low in trust in the high court.

Although none of the President's three proposals are viewed as having any chance in the current frosty political climate, UK election law specialist and author of The Court vs. the Voters Joshua Douglas says they can at least start a wider conversation about ways to restore the courts standing.

Biden's proposals include an enforceable code of ethics, term limits for justices, and a constitutional amendment that would limit the justices' recent decision on presidential immunity. Douglas says all makes sense, but he sees limited terms as having several benefits.

"We need court reform, but I don't think just court packing — that some people have talked about and certainly was a threat during FDR's time — is the right idea," Douglas says. "But something like term limits where we have a regular rotation of justices, I think, would lower the temperature of the nomination battle, which hopefully could get the justices to focus more on the rule of law and less on having their pure ideological feelings come out in their opinions."

And those opinions are becoming increasingly foregone conclusions.

"In the most high salience and hot-button issues, you see a predictable currently 6-3 conservative court. It used to be a 5-4 court. And I think we shouldn't be able to predict the outcome in the most hot button cases involving social issues," Douglas tells WUKY.

An enforceable ethics code should be a "no-brainer," he adds, noting all other federal justices are bound by such a code.

While Douglas supports all three proposals, he acknowledges their status as starting points rather than realistic policy ideas in a time of sharply divided government. They leave open a number of questions, which require debate.

"It will be hard to implement. There's some question as to whether Congress could impose term limits on the justices itself themselves, or whether it needs to be a Constitutional Amendment," Douglas says. "So... the idea here is to start the conversation less than actual proposals that could get passed any time soon."

Critics, however, argue Biden's recommended changes are about Democrats trying to interfere with "a court they don't agree with."

Josh James fell in love with college radio at Western Kentucky University's student station, New Rock 92 (now Revolution 91.7). After working as a DJ and program director, he knew he wanted to come home to Lexington and try his hand in public radio.